2 minutes read

Are you a pizza purist or do you like to experiment? When it comes to pizza, everyone has their favorite combos, but which are America’s favorite pizza toppings?

According to Mintel’s latest Pizza Restaurant research in the US, more than half of consumers say that they usually order pepperoni (65%), sausage (54%), or mushroom (51%). This is followed by: extra cheese (45%), onion (39%), green pepper (37%), olive (34%), bacon (31%), ham (29%) and pineapple (21%).

When it comes to gender, men are much more likely than women to order bacon (38% of men v 24% of women), sausage (60% v 48%), pepperoni (71% v 60%), and ham pizzas (34% v 25%). In comparison, women prefer vegetable options, such as olives (36% of women v 33% of men), onion (40% v 38%), green pepper (38% v 36%).

Topping preferences also differ according to age. Consumers aged 18-24 show a stronger preference for bacon (40% of this age group v 31% on average), extra cheese (54% v 45%), ham (36% v 29%), and pineapple (26% v 21%). On the other hand, consumers aged 65+ are much less likely to order mushrooms (58% v 51% on average), and those aged 55-64 show a strong preference for onions (47% v 39% on average).

And while pizza topping preferences are fairly similar among regions, there are a few exceptions. Of all regions, Northeast consumers may be the more open to innovative new combinations, with 7% saying the don’t order the usual toppings v 3% on average.
Meanwhile, consumers from the Midwest are much more likely to select mushroom (58% v 51% on average), onion (44% v 39%), and green pepper (41% v 37%) than any other region, making the supreme pizza combination very popular.

Consumers in the South are much more likely to order extra cheese (54% v 45% on average), bacon (34% v 31%), and ham (35% v 29%), creating an opportunity to sell meat-lover-type pizzas. Last, consumers located in the West show a greater interest in olives (47% v 34%) and pineapple (27% v 21%) as their usual pizza toppings.

Overall, the pizza restaurant market in the US has grown throughout the recession and is continuing to do so in the weak economy. Pizza restaurant sales grew 10% from 2007-11 and are expected to hit $37.7 billion in 2012. Growth of 16.7% is predicted from 2012-17, reaching $44 billion in 2017 as the economy strengthens and consumers return to patterns that are close to pre-recessionary spending.

Bethany Wall
More from Mintel
  • The US Pizza Market
    Discover what's happening in the US Pizza Market and what attributes warrant a higher pizza price in 2021...
    Explore this research
  • Mintel 2026 Global Predictions
    2026 Global Predictions
    Our Predictions go beyond traditional trend analysis. Download to get the predictive intelligence and strategic framework to shape the future of your industry in 2026 and beyond. ...
    Download now
  • Mintel Consulting
    Are you after more tailored solutions to help drive Consumer Demand, Market Expansion or Innovation Strategy?
    Ask for a customised strategic solution from Mintel Consulting today....
    Find out more
Subscribe to Mintel Spotlight
Related articles
April 15, 2026
This article distils the latest global drinks industry trends, consumer behaviours and emerging opportunities, powered by Mintel’s expert analysis and proprietary data.
March 23, 2026
Expo West 2026 offered a clear reflection of several long-running shifts Mintel has been tracking across health, nutrition, and consumer expectations. What stood out most this year was less about…
March 23, 2026
Consumer behaviour in food and drink is shifting fast. Health optimisation, new functional expectations, changing flavour cues and cultural influence are reshaping what consumers want, and how categories will grow.

Free market intelligence downloads